New Orleans Saints Quarterback History: From Manning To Brees

The New Orleans Saints have a storied history in the National Football League (NFL), marked by periods of struggle and triumph. Central to their journey has been the quarterback position, a role that has seen a revolving door of faces, each leaving their unique imprint on the franchise. From the early days of Archie Manning to the Super Bowl glory led by Drew Brees, the Saints' quarterback legacy is a compelling narrative of perseverance, talent, and the pursuit of excellence. This article delves into the comprehensive history of New Orleans Saints quarterbacks, exploring the highs, the lows, and the enduring impact these players have had on the team and its passionate fanbase.

Early Years and the Archie Manning Era

Looking back at the early years, the New Orleans Saints struggled to find consistency at the quarterback position, cycling through various players in their formative seasons. The team, founded in 1967, initially faced challenges in establishing a competitive roster, and the quarterback role was no exception. Names like Billy Kilmer, Gary Cuozzo, and Edd Hargett donned the black and gold, each showing flashes of potential but ultimately failing to solidify themselves as long-term solutions. These early quarterbacks played during a time when the Saints were still finding their identity, often facing formidable opponents and struggling to build a winning culture. The constant turnover at quarterback reflected the team's overall instability and search for a franchise cornerstone.

The arrival of Archie Manning in 1971 marked a turning point, ushering in an era that would define the Saints for over a decade. Manning, drafted second overall, brought a sense of hope and excitement to a franchise hungry for success. His strong arm, intelligence, and leadership qualities were immediately evident, making him a fan favorite and the face of the Saints. Despite playing on teams that often struggled, Manning consistently delivered stellar individual performances, showcasing his resilience and talent. He endured numerous sacks and played behind an offensive line that frequently faltered, yet he remained a steady presence, earning Pro Bowl selections in 1978 and 1979.

While Archie Manning never led the Saints to the playoffs, his contributions to the franchise extend far beyond wins and losses. He provided stability at the quarterback position, becoming the team's all-time leader in passing yards and touchdowns during his tenure. Manning's impact resonated deeply with the Saints' faithful, who admired his toughness and unwavering commitment to the team. His presence helped cultivate a passionate fanbase that stuck with the Saints through thick and thin. Moreover, Manning's legacy as a player and a person made him an iconic figure in New Orleans, transcending the sport of football. His contributions laid the groundwork for future quarterbacks and set a standard of professionalism and dedication that remains a part of the Saints' culture.

The Quarterback Carousel: Post-Manning Era

Following the departure of Archie Manning in 1982, the New Orleans Saints entered a period characterized by inconsistency and instability at the quarterback position. The team struggled to find a suitable replacement for their long-time signal-caller, leading to a carousel of quarterbacks taking snaps under center. This era underscored the importance of quarterback stability in building a successful NFL franchise, as the Saints searched for a player who could provide consistent performance and leadership.

Names like Ken Stabler, Dave Wilson, and Bobby Hebert all had stints as the Saints' starting quarterback during this period. Stabler, a former Super Bowl champion with the Oakland Raiders, brought veteran experience to New Orleans, but his time with the team was short-lived. Wilson, a homegrown talent from Tulane University, showed promise but struggled with consistency. Hebert, who arrived in 1985, provided a spark and led the Saints to their first-ever playoff appearance in 1987. However, Hebert's tenure was marked by both success and controversy, and he eventually left the team in 1989. Ulysses Bentley IV: The Rising Football Star's Story

The revolving door at quarterback highlighted the challenges the Saints faced in finding a long-term solution. The team's struggles during this period underscored the critical role the quarterback position plays in a team's success. Without a consistent presence under center, the Saints found it difficult to compete in a tough NFC West division. The search for a franchise quarterback became a recurring theme, as the team's fortunes fluctuated with each change under center. This period served as a reminder of the importance of stability and leadership at the quarterback position and set the stage for the arrival of a player who would finally bring sustained success to New Orleans.

The Jim Everett and Heath Shuler Years

The early to mid-1990s saw the New Orleans Saints continue their search for quarterback stability, with the team making notable acquisitions in Jim Everett and Heath Shuler. These quarterbacks were brought in with the hope of providing long-term solutions, but their tenures ultimately fell short of expectations, contributing to the team's ongoing struggles at the position.

Jim Everett arrived in New Orleans in 1994 via a trade with the Los Angeles Rams. Everett, a Pro Bowl quarterback with a strong arm, was expected to bring a veteran presence and offensive firepower to the Saints. However, his time in New Orleans was marked by inconsistency and a perceived lack of leadership. While Everett had moments of brilliance, he often struggled with accuracy and decision-making, failing to recapture the form he displayed with the Rams. His tenure with the Saints lasted just three seasons, and he was eventually released after the 1996 season.

Following Everett's departure, the Saints turned to Heath Shuler, whom they selected with the third overall pick in the 1994 NFL Draft. Shuler, a highly touted prospect out of the University of Tennessee, was seen as a potential franchise quarterback. However, his NFL career was plagued by injuries and inconsistent play. Shuler struggled to adapt to the professional game, and his time with the Saints was marred by numerous setbacks. He played in just nine games for the team before being traded to the Washington Redskins in 1997.

The failed tenures of Everett and Shuler underscored the challenges the Saints faced in finding a quarterback who could lead the team to sustained success. The team's struggles during this period highlighted the importance of not only talent but also fit and development in the quarterback position. The Saints' ongoing search for a franchise quarterback would continue into the late 1990s, as they looked for a player who could finally bring stability and leadership to the position.

The Jeff Blake and Aaron Brooks Era

The late 1990s and early 2000s brought a mix of veteran experience and youthful potential to the New Orleans Saints' quarterback position, with Jeff Blake and Aaron Brooks taking the reins. These quarterbacks each had their moments, providing glimpses of hope and excitement for the Saints' faithful. While neither ultimately became the long-term answer, they played significant roles in the team's journey towards stability and success.

Jeff Blake joined the Saints in 2000, bringing a veteran presence and a reputation for a strong arm. Blake's arrival provided a temporary solution at quarterback, and he quickly became a fan favorite with his exciting style of play. He led the Saints to an impressive 10-6 record in his first season, guiding the team to its first-ever NFC West title and a playoff victory. Blake's leadership and performance earned him Pro Bowl recognition, and he provided a sense of optimism for the Saints' future. However, injuries and inconsistent play limited his time in New Orleans, and he eventually moved on after the 2001 season.

Aaron Brooks, acquired in a trade with the Green Bay Packers in 2000, represented a younger, more mobile option at quarterback. Brooks possessed a strong arm and the ability to make plays with his legs, adding a dynamic element to the Saints' offense. He became the team's starter in 2003 and led the Saints to several successful seasons, including a playoff appearance in 2006. Brooks' tenure was marked by both highs and lows, as he demonstrated flashes of brilliance but also struggled with turnovers and decision-making. Despite his inconsistencies, Brooks holds a significant place in Saints history, as he helped the team remain competitive during a crucial period.

The Jeff Blake and Aaron Brooks era provided a bridge to the future for the Saints, as the team continued its quest for a franchise quarterback. These quarterbacks brought moments of excitement and success, setting the stage for the arrival of a player who would ultimately lead the Saints to their greatest triumph. Days Until May 23rd: Calculate The Countdown

The Drew Brees Era: A Super Bowl Champion

The arrival of Drew Brees in 2006 marked a transformative moment in New Orleans Saints history, ushering in an era of unprecedented success and cementing his legacy as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. Brees, signed as a free agent after a shoulder injury raised concerns about his long-term prospects, quickly proved to be the missing piece the Saints had been searching for. His leadership, accuracy, and unwavering dedication to the team and the city of New Orleans made him an instant icon.

From his first season with the Saints, Brees showcased his exceptional talent and leadership qualities. He quickly formed a strong connection with head coach Sean Payton, and together they crafted a high-powered offense that consistently ranked among the league's best. Brees' ability to read defenses, make accurate throws, and command the huddle set him apart, and he became the driving force behind the Saints' resurgence. In 2006, he led the team to a 10-6 record and an NFC Championship Game appearance, providing a glimmer of hope for a city still recovering from the devastation of Hurricane Katrina.

The pinnacle of the Drew Brees era came in 2009, when he led the Saints to their first-ever Super Bowl victory. In Super Bowl XLIV, Brees delivered a masterful performance, throwing for 288 yards and two touchdowns en route to earning Super Bowl MVP honors. The Saints' Super Bowl triumph was a watershed moment for the franchise and the city of New Orleans, providing a sense of unity and celebration in the aftermath of tragedy. Brees' leadership and performance on the field were instrumental in the team's success, and he became a symbol of hope and resilience for the entire region.

Throughout his tenure with the Saints, Drew Brees consistently set records and achieved milestones that solidified his place in NFL history. He holds numerous passing records, including career passing yards and career touchdown passes. Brees' accuracy, consistency, and longevity were unmatched, and he remained a dominant force well into his 40s. Beyond his on-field accomplishments, Brees' commitment to the community made him a beloved figure in New Orleans. His charitable work and dedication to helping those in need further cemented his legacy as one of the most respected and admired players in NFL history. The Drew Brees era represents the most successful period in Saints history, and his contributions will forever be cherished by the team and its fans. Jewish Players In The NBA: History, Impact, And Notable Figures

Post-Brees Era and the Search for the Next Leader

Following the retirement of Drew Brees in 2021, the New Orleans Saints entered a new chapter, embarking on the challenging task of finding their next franchise quarterback. The departure of Brees left a significant void both on and off the field, as the team looked to identify a player who could lead them into the future. The post-Brees era has been marked by a combination of veteran acquisitions and draft selections, as the Saints explore various avenues to address the quarterback position.

In the immediate aftermath of Brees' retirement, the Saints turned to veteran quarterbacks Jameis Winston and Taysom Hill to fill the void. Winston, a former first overall pick with a strong arm, showed flashes of potential but also struggled with turnovers. Hill, a versatile player known for his running ability and athleticism, provided a unique dimension to the Saints' offense. However, neither Winston nor Hill ultimately solidified themselves as the long-term answer, leading the team to continue its search.

The Saints have also explored the NFL Draft as a means of finding their next franchise quarterback. The team has invested draft capital in the position, selecting players like Ian Book in the fourth round of the 2021 NFL Draft. While Book showed promise, he remains a developmental prospect, and the Saints continue to evaluate their options at quarterback. The team's approach reflects the complexities of finding a franchise quarterback, a process that often requires patience, evaluation, and a bit of luck.

The post-Brees era represents a transitional period for the New Orleans Saints, as the team navigates the challenges of replacing a legendary player. The search for the next leader at quarterback is an ongoing process, and the Saints are committed to exploring all avenues to find the right fit. The team's future success hinges on identifying and developing a quarterback who can lead them back to contention, carrying on the legacy of excellence established during the Drew Brees era.

FAQ: New Orleans Saints Quarterback History

Who was the first quarterback for the New Orleans Saints?

The first quarterback for the New Orleans Saints was Billy Kilmer, who started for the team in their inaugural season in 1967. Kilmer played for the Saints for four seasons, during which he showcased his talent and helped establish the team's early identity.

How long did Archie Manning play for the New Orleans Saints?

Archie Manning played for the New Orleans Saints for 11 seasons, from 1971 to 1982. During his tenure, Manning became a beloved figure in New Orleans, known for his resilience and dedication to the team, even amidst challenging circumstances.

Why was the Drew Brees era so important for the Saints franchise?

The Drew Brees era was incredibly important for the Saints franchise because he led the team to their first Super Bowl victory in 2009. Beyond the Super Bowl win, Brees brought consistent success and leadership to the team, transforming the Saints into perennial contenders and becoming a symbol of hope for the city of New Orleans.

What records does Drew Brees hold with the New Orleans Saints?

Drew Brees holds numerous records with the New Orleans Saints, including most passing yards, most passing touchdowns, and highest completion percentage. His exceptional accuracy and prolific passing ability made him one of the most statistically dominant quarterbacks in NFL history.

How did the Saints fare after Drew Brees retired from the NFL?

After Drew Brees retired in 2021, the New Orleans Saints faced a period of transition, exploring different quarterback options to fill the void. The team utilized both veteran acquisitions and draft selections in their search for the next franchise quarterback, navigating the challenges of replacing a legendary player.

What are some key factors the Saints consider when drafting a new quarterback?

When drafting a new quarterback, the Saints consider factors such as arm strength, accuracy, decision-making ability, and leadership qualities. They also evaluate a player's fit within their offensive system and their potential for development in the NFL.

Which quarterbacks have led the Saints to the playoffs in their history?

Several quarterbacks have led the Saints to the playoffs, including Bobby Hebert, Jim Everett, Aaron Brooks, and Drew Brees. Each of these quarterbacks played a role in the team's postseason appearances, contributing to the Saints' overall history and success.

How has the quarterback position evolved in Saints history?

The quarterback position in Saints history has evolved from a period of instability and searching in the early years to an era of sustained success and leadership under Drew Brees. The team's journey at quarterback reflects their overall growth and development as a franchise in the NFL.

External Links:

  1. https://www.nfl.com/
  2. https://www.espn.com/nfl/team/history/_/name/no/new-orleans-saints
  3. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/teams/nor/
  4. https://www.neworleanssaints.com/
  5. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_New_Orleans_Saints
Photo of Robert M. Wachter

Robert M. Wachter

Professor, Medicine Chair, Department of Medicine ·

Robert M. Bob Wachter is an academic physician and author. He is on the faculty of University of California, San Francisco, where he is chairman of the Department of Medicine, the Lynne and Marc Benioff Endowed Chair in Hospital Medicine, and the Holly Smith Distinguished Professor in Science and Medicine