Fantasy Football Week 5: Who To Start, Sit, And Watch

Navigating your fantasy football lineup for Week 5 requires careful consideration as bye weeks and injuries begin to impact decisions. This guide provides insights into players to start, potential sits, and those worth keeping an eye on, helping you optimize your roster for a successful week. Making informed choices based on matchups, player performance, and team dynamics is crucial for fantasy football success.

Quarterbacks: Start ‘Em, Sit ‘Em, Watch

Deciding which quarterback to start can be a pivotal choice in fantasy football. Analyze matchups, recent performances, and injury reports to make the best decision for your team. Identifying quarterbacks in favorable situations is essential for maximizing your potential points each week. Let's dive into some quarterbacks to consider for Week 5.

Start ‘Em

When evaluating quarterbacks to start, focusing on those with favorable matchups and consistent performance is key. A quarterback facing a defense known to give up passing yards can be a goldmine for fantasy points. Identifying these players requires careful analysis of defensive stats and trends.

Patrick Mahomes (Kansas City Chiefs): Mahomes is consistently a top fantasy performer, and Week 5 is no exception. His ability to make plays both through the air and with his legs makes him a reliable starter every week. The Chiefs' offense is built around Mahomes's skillset, ensuring a high floor and ceiling for fantasy production. You can rely on Mahomes to deliver strong performances week in and week out.

Josh Allen (Buffalo Bills): Allen's dual-threat capabilities make him a weekly must-start in fantasy football. His strong arm and rushing ability provide multiple avenues for scoring fantasy points. The Bills' offense is designed to capitalize on Allen's strengths, making him a consistent top-tier quarterback option. Start Allen with confidence, knowing he can produce both through the air and on the ground.

Jalen Hurts (Philadelphia Eagles): Hurts continues to be a dynamic fantasy option due to his rushing prowess and improved passing skills. His ability to score touchdowns on the ground adds a significant boost to his fantasy value. The Eagles' offense is tailored to Hurts's strengths, making him a reliable starter each week. Hurts's dual-threat ability makes him a consistent top-5 quarterback in fantasy football.

Sit ‘Em

Knowing which quarterbacks to bench is just as important as knowing who to start. Difficult matchups, injuries, or inconsistent performance can all be reasons to keep a quarterback on your bench. Making the right sit decisions can save you from a disappointing week in your fantasy league.

Russell Wilson (Denver Broncos): Wilson has struggled to find consistency this season, making him a risky start in Week 5. The Broncos' offense has been inconsistent, and Wilson's performance has suffered as a result. Consider benching Wilson in favor of a more reliable option this week. His struggles to connect with his receivers and a tough upcoming matchup make him a risky play.

Deshaun Watson (Cleveland Browns): Watson's performance has been underwhelming, and his injury status adds further uncertainty. The Browns' offense has not fully clicked with Watson under center, leading to inconsistent fantasy outputs. Until Watson shows more consistency, it's best to keep him on the bench. His health and performance concerns make him a risky start in Week 5.

Kenny Pickett (Pittsburgh Steelers): Pickett has struggled to produce consistent fantasy numbers, making him a difficult player to trust in your starting lineup. The Steelers' offense has faced challenges, and Pickett's performance has reflected those struggles. Consider other options at quarterback this week. Pickett needs to show improvement before he can be considered a reliable fantasy starter.

Watch

Identifying quarterbacks with potential upside is crucial for long-term fantasy success. These players may not be every-week starters, but they possess the potential to break out in favorable matchups or due to changes in their team's situation. Keeping an eye on these quarterbacks can give you a competitive edge in your league.

Jordan Love (Green Bay Packers): Love has shown flashes of potential but needs to develop more consistency. His arm talent is undeniable, but he is still learning to navigate NFL defenses. Monitor Love's progress, as he could become a valuable fantasy asset later in the season. He has the potential to be a solid fantasy quarterback, but he needs more experience.

C.J. Stroud (Houston Texans): Stroud has impressed early in his rookie season and could emerge as a solid fantasy option. His strong arm and ability to read defenses make him an intriguing player to watch. As Stroud gains more experience, he could become a reliable starter in fantasy leagues. Keep an eye on Stroud, as he has the potential to be a fantasy star.

Anthony Richardson (Indianapolis Colts): Richardson's rushing ability gives him a high fantasy ceiling, but his passing accuracy needs improvement. His athleticism makes him a threat to score on the ground, but he needs to develop as a passer to become a consistent fantasy option. Monitor Richardson's progress, as he has the potential to be a fantasy football game-changer. His dual-threat ability makes him an exciting player to watch. Amari Cooper: Retirement Rumors, Career, And What's Next

Running Backs: Start ‘Em, Sit ‘Em, Watch

Running back decisions can make or break your fantasy week. Identifying the right players to start, sit, and watch is crucial for success. Focus on matchups, usage, and injury reports to make informed decisions about your running back slots. Let's break down some running backs to consider for Week 5.

Start ‘Em

Starting the right running backs can provide a significant advantage in fantasy football. Look for running backs with favorable matchups, high usage rates, and the potential for touchdowns. These players are the foundation of a successful fantasy team. Prioritize running backs who are heavily involved in their team's offense.

Christian McCaffrey (San Francisco 49ers): McCaffrey is a weekly must-start due to his dual-threat ability and consistent production. His involvement in both the running and passing game gives him a high floor and ceiling. The 49ers' offense revolves around McCaffrey, making him a fantasy superstar. Start McCaffrey with confidence every week.

Bijan Robinson (Atlanta Falcons): Robinson has quickly established himself as a top fantasy running back. His talent and the Falcons' commitment to the run make him a reliable starter. Robinson's ability to break tackles and gain yards after contact makes him a valuable fantasy asset. Expect Robinson to continue to produce strong numbers throughout the season.

Tony Pollard (Dallas Cowboys): Pollard is the lead back in a potent Cowboys offense and has a favorable matchup in Week 5. His explosiveness and ability to make big plays make him a weekly threat. The Cowboys' offensive line is among the best in the league, creating opportunities for Pollard to succeed. Pollard's potential for high-scoring games makes him a must-start.

Sit ‘Em

Knowing which running backs to sit is crucial for avoiding disappointing performances. Difficult matchups, limited roles, or injury concerns can all be reasons to keep a running back on your bench. Making the right sit decisions can save your fantasy week.

Miles Sanders (Carolina Panthers): Sanders has struggled to find consistency this season and faces a tough matchup in Week 5. The Panthers' offense has been inconsistent, and Sanders has not been able to establish himself as a reliable fantasy option. Consider benching Sanders until he shows signs of improvement. His limited production makes him a risky start.

Dameon Pierce (Houston Texans): Pierce's production has been underwhelming, and he faces competition for touches in the Texans' backfield. The Texans' offense has been inconsistent, and Pierce's role has diminished. Until Pierce's usage increases, it's best to keep him on the bench. His inconsistent performance makes him a difficult player to trust.

AJ Dillon (Green Bay Packers): Dillon has not lived up to expectations and is not a reliable fantasy option. His touches have been limited, and he has not been able to capitalize on his opportunities. Consider other options at running back this week. Dillon's lack of production makes him a risky start.

Watch

Identifying running backs with breakout potential can give you a significant edge in your fantasy league. These players may be backups or in uncertain situations, but they have the talent and opportunity to become valuable fantasy assets. Keeping an eye on these players can help you stay ahead of the competition.

Jerome Ford (Cleveland Browns): Ford has shown flashes of potential and could see an increased role in the Browns' offense. His ability to run between the tackles and catch passes out of the backfield makes him an intriguing player. Monitor Ford's usage, as he could become a valuable fantasy asset. Ford's versatility makes him an exciting player to watch.

Zach Charbonnet (Seattle Seahawks): Charbonnet is a talented rookie who could see more opportunities as the season progresses. His size and power make him a threat in short-yardage situations. Keep an eye on Charbonnet, as he could emerge as a valuable fantasy option. His potential for increased touches makes him a player to watch.

Rashaad Penny (Philadelphia Eagles): Penny is a talented runner who has struggled with injuries throughout his career. If he can stay healthy, he could be a valuable fantasy asset. Monitor Penny's health and usage, as he has the potential to break out. Penny's explosiveness makes him an intriguing player to watch.

Wide Receivers: Start ‘Em, Sit ‘Em, Watch

The wide receiver position is crucial in fantasy football, and making the right start/sit decisions can significantly impact your team's success. Consider matchups, target share, and quarterback performance when evaluating wide receivers. Let's examine some wide receivers to target, avoid, and monitor in Week 5.

Start ‘Em

Starting high-performing wide receivers with favorable matchups is essential for fantasy success. Look for receivers who are their team's primary targets and have a history of producing consistent results. These players are the cornerstones of a strong fantasy team.

Justin Jefferson (Minnesota Vikings): Jefferson is a weekly must-start due to his elite talent and high target share. His ability to make contested catches and gain yards after the catch makes him a fantasy superstar. The Vikings' offense is built around Jefferson, ensuring he gets plenty of opportunities. Start Jefferson with confidence every week.

Ja’Marr Chase (Cincinnati Bengals): Chase is a top-tier wide receiver with the potential for explosive performances. His connection with Joe Burrow makes him a consistent threat for touchdowns and big plays. The Bengals' offense is designed to get Chase the ball, making him a must-start. Chase's playmaking ability makes him a valuable fantasy asset.

A.J. Brown (Philadelphia Eagles): Brown is the Eagles' primary receiver and has a favorable matchup in Week 5. His size and speed make him a difficult matchup for opposing cornerbacks. The Eagles' offense is among the most potent in the league, providing Brown with ample opportunities. Brown's potential for big games makes him a must-start.

Sit ‘Em

Knowing which wide receivers to sit is crucial for avoiding disappointing performances. Difficult matchups, inconsistent quarterback play, or competition for targets can all be reasons to keep a wide receiver on your bench. Making the right sit decisions can save your fantasy week.

Jerry Jeudy (Denver Broncos): Jeudy has struggled to produce consistent fantasy numbers this season, making him a risky start in Week 5. The Broncos' offense has been inconsistent, and Jeudy has not been able to establish himself as a reliable fantasy option. Consider benching Jeudy until he shows signs of improvement. His limited production makes him a risky start.

Michael Thomas (New Orleans Saints): Thomas's production has been inconsistent, and his injury history adds further uncertainty. The Saints' offense has been unpredictable, and Thomas has not been able to consistently produce. Until Thomas shows more consistency, it's best to keep him on the bench. His health and performance concerns make him a risky start in Week 5.

Kadarius Toney (Kansas City Chiefs): Toney has not lived up to expectations and is not a reliable fantasy option. His touches have been limited, and he has struggled to stay healthy. Consider other options at wide receiver this week. Toney's lack of production and injury concerns make him a risky start.

Watch

Identifying wide receivers with breakout potential can give you a significant edge in your fantasy league. These players may be in uncertain situations, but they have the talent and opportunity to become valuable fantasy assets. Keeping an eye on these players can help you stay ahead of the competition.

George Pickens (Pittsburgh Steelers): Pickens has shown flashes of potential and could see an increased role in the Steelers' offense. His ability to make contested catches and gain yards downfield makes him an intriguing player. Monitor Pickens' usage, as he could become a valuable fantasy asset. Pickens' big-play ability makes him an exciting player to watch.

Christian Watson (Green Bay Packers): Watson is a talented receiver who could emerge as a top target for Jordan Love. His size and speed make him a threat downfield. Keep an eye on Watson, as he could become a valuable fantasy option. His potential for big plays makes him a player to watch.

Tank Dell (Houston Texans): Dell has impressed early in his rookie season and could become a reliable target for C.J. Stroud. His quickness and ability to get open make him an intriguing player. Monitor Dell's progress, as he has the potential to be a fantasy star. His rapport with Stroud makes him an exciting player to watch. Who Was Earl Little Jr.? Unraveling The Mystery

Tight Ends: Start ‘Em, Sit ‘Em, Watch

The tight end position can be a source of frustration in fantasy football due to its inconsistency. Identifying reliable starters is crucial for success. Consider matchups, target share, and quarterback tendencies when evaluating tight ends. Let's look at some tight ends to consider for Week 5.

Start ‘Em

Starting a consistent tight end can provide a significant advantage in fantasy football. Look for tight ends who are heavily involved in their team's passing game and have a knack for scoring touchdowns. These players can be difference-makers in your lineup.

Travis Kelce (Kansas City Chiefs): Kelce is the gold standard at the tight end position and a weekly must-start. His connection with Patrick Mahomes makes him a consistent threat for big games. The Chiefs' offense is designed to get Kelce the ball, making him a fantasy superstar. Start Kelce with confidence every week.

Mark Andrews (Baltimore Ravens): Andrews is a top-tier tight end who is heavily involved in the Ravens' passing game. His ability to make tough catches and score touchdowns makes him a valuable fantasy asset. The Ravens' offense relies on Andrews, making him a reliable starter. Andrews' consistency makes him a must-start.

T.J. Hockenson (Minnesota Vikings): Hockenson is a key part of the Vikings' passing attack and has a favorable matchup in Week 5. His ability to gain yards after the catch makes him a valuable fantasy asset. The Vikings' offense targets Hockenson frequently, making him a reliable starter. Hockenson's high target share makes him a must-start.

Sit ‘Em

Knowing which tight ends to sit is crucial for avoiding disappointing performances. Difficult matchups, limited roles, or inconsistent quarterback play can all be reasons to keep a tight end on your bench. Making the right sit decisions can save your fantasy week.

Dalton Schultz (Houston Texans): Schultz's production has been inconsistent, making him a risky start in Week 5. The Texans' offense has been unpredictable, and Schultz has not been able to establish himself as a reliable fantasy option. Consider benching Schultz until he shows signs of improvement. His limited production makes him a risky start.

Tyler Higbee (Los Angeles Rams): Higbee's production has been underwhelming, and he faces competition for targets in the Rams' offense. The Rams' offense has been inconsistent, and Higbee's role has diminished. Until Higbee's usage increases, it's best to keep him on the bench. His inconsistent performance makes him a difficult player to trust.

Cole Kmet (Chicago Bears): Kmet has not lived up to expectations and is not a reliable fantasy option. His touches have been limited, and he has not been able to capitalize on his opportunities. Consider other options at tight end this week. Kmet's lack of production makes him a risky start.

Watch

Identifying tight ends with breakout potential can give you a significant edge in your fantasy league. These players may be in uncertain situations, but they have the talent and opportunity to become valuable fantasy assets. Keeping an eye on these players can help you stay ahead of the competition.

Luke Musgrave (Green Bay Packers): Musgrave has shown flashes of potential and could become a reliable target for Jordan Love. His athleticism and receiving ability make him an intriguing player. Monitor Musgrave's usage, as he could become a valuable fantasy asset. Musgrave's potential makes him an exciting player to watch.

Sam LaPorta (Detroit Lions): LaPorta has impressed early in his rookie season and could become a key part of the Lions' passing game. His ability to make contested catches makes him an intriguing player. Keep an eye on LaPorta, as he could emerge as a valuable fantasy option. LaPorta's early success makes him a player to watch.

Evan Engram (Jacksonville Jaguars): Engram is a talented tight end who could see an increased role in the Jaguars' offense. His speed and receiving ability make him a threat downfield. Monitor Engram's usage, as he has the potential to break out. Engram's versatility makes him an intriguing player to watch.

FAQs About Week 5 Fantasy Football

What are the key factors to consider when deciding who to start in Week 5?

When deciding who to start, consider factors such as player matchups, recent performance, injury status, and the overall strength of their team's offense. Analyzing these elements can help you make informed decisions and optimize your lineup for the best possible outcome each week.

How do bye weeks impact fantasy football decisions in Week 5?

Bye weeks can significantly impact your fantasy lineup by removing key players from your available roster. It’s crucial to check which teams have a bye in Week 5 and plan accordingly, ensuring you have adequate replacements to fill those roster spots so your team can compete effectively.

What strategies can I use to identify potential breakout players for Week 5?

To identify potential breakout players, focus on players with favorable matchups, those who have seen an increase in usage recently, or players who may benefit from injuries to teammates. Watching practice reports and analyzing game film can also provide valuable insights into potential breakout candidates.

How should I handle injured players in my fantasy football lineup for Week 5?

For injured players, closely monitor their injury status through official team reports and reliable news sources. If a player is ruled out or is questionable, it’s generally best to have a backup plan in place. Consider their potential replacements and ensure you have someone ready to step into their role if needed.

What are some common mistakes to avoid when setting my fantasy lineup for Week 5?

Common mistakes to avoid include overreacting to one bad game, starting players with tough matchups, and not considering bye weeks or injuries. Always do your research, weigh all factors, and make informed decisions based on the available information to optimize your lineup effectively.

Which defenses offer the best matchups for fantasy quarterbacks in Week 5?

Defenses that have struggled against the pass or have key defensive players injured often provide the best matchups for fantasy quarterbacks. Researching defensive statistics and injury reports can help you identify favorable matchups and exploit them for fantasy points.

How important is it to stream defenses in fantasy football, and what should I look for in Week 5?

Streaming defenses can be a viable strategy in fantasy football, especially if you don't have an elite defense on your roster. Look for defenses facing offenses that are prone to turnovers or have struggling quarterbacks. Matchups and recent performance are key factors to consider when streaming defenses.

What role do tight ends play in fantasy football, and who are some sleepers for Week 5?

Tight ends can be valuable assets in fantasy football, especially those who are heavily targeted in their team's passing game. Sleepers for Week 5 might include tight ends facing favorable matchups or those who have seen an increase in targets due to injuries or changes in the offense. Monitoring target distribution and matchups can help identify potential sleeper candidates. John Crawley: The TikTok Star You Need To Know

By carefully analyzing matchups, player performance, and team dynamics, you can make informed decisions to optimize your fantasy football lineup for Week 5. Good luck!

Photo of Robert M. Wachter

Robert M. Wachter

Professor, Medicine Chair, Department of Medicine ·

Robert M. Bob Wachter is an academic physician and author. He is on the faculty of University of California, San Francisco, where he is chairman of the Department of Medicine, the Lynne and Marc Benioff Endowed Chair in Hospital Medicine, and the Holly Smith Distinguished Professor in Science and Medicine