Dallas Cowboys Draft Grade: Analysis And Review

The Dallas Cowboys' 2024 NFL Draft performance is under scrutiny, with analysts and fans eager to assess how well the team addressed its needs and secured promising talent for the future. This comprehensive analysis delves into each pick, evaluating the potential impact of the newest Cowboys and assigning an overall grade to the draft class. The Cowboys aimed to bolster their offensive line, defensive prowess, and receiving corps through this draft, and the success of their selections will be pivotal in shaping their competitiveness in the upcoming seasons. The team's strategy (needs verification) focused on a blend of immediate contributors and developmental prospects, reflecting a long-term vision for sustained success.

Dallas Cowboys 2024 Draft Overview

The Dallas Cowboys entered the 2024 NFL Draft with several key needs, primarily focusing on reinforcing their offensive line, adding depth to their defensive front, and potentially finding another receiving target for Dak Prescott. Evaluating the Cowboys' draft involves considering not only the talent acquired but also the value obtained at each draft slot. The Cowboys had the 24th overall pick in the first round, setting the stage for a crucial decision that could significantly impact their roster. This overview examines the Cowboys' draft selections, assessing each pick's potential fit within the team's scheme and overall contribution to the roster's competitiveness.

First Round Selection: Tyler Guyton, OT, Oklahoma

The Cowboys selected Tyler Guyton, an offensive tackle from Oklahoma, with their first-round pick. This pick addresses the glaring need for offensive line reinforcement following the departure of veteran tackle Tyron Smith. Guyton is known for his exceptional athleticism and raw potential, possessing the physical tools to become a dominant left tackle in the NFL. His pass-blocking skills are particularly noteworthy, making him an ideal candidate to protect Dak Prescott's blindside. However, Guyton is still relatively inexperienced, having only started one full season in college, which means he will require coaching and development to refine his technique and consistency. The Cowboys are betting on his upside, hoping he can quickly adapt to the pro level and provide stability to their offensive line.

Guyton’s selection reflects the Cowboys' commitment to prioritizing the offensive line, a critical component for both the running and passing game. His addition should provide immediate competition and potential for a long-term solution at a premium position. The investment in Guyton underscores the importance the team places on protecting their quarterback and establishing a strong foundation for their offensive attack. The Cowboys' coaches will play a crucial role in molding Guyton's raw talent into a polished NFL starter, and his development will be a key storyline to follow in the coming seasons.

Second Round Selection: Marshawn Kneeland, DE, Western Michigan

In the second round, the Cowboys chose Marshawn Kneeland, a defensive end from Western Michigan. This pick is aimed at bolstering their defensive line depth and adding a powerful edge rusher to their defensive scheme. Kneeland is a physical player known for his strength and ability to set the edge against the run. His versatility allows him to play multiple positions along the defensive line, offering valuable flexibility for defensive coordinator Mike Zimmer. Kneeland’s high motor and relentless pursuit of the quarterback are traits that the Cowboys' coaching staff values highly. Ben Arnet Komu: Remembering A Life

Kneeland's selection provides the Cowboys with a potential long-term solution at defensive end, addressing the need for additional pass-rushing talent. His ability to contribute both against the run and the pass makes him a valuable asset, and his work ethic suggests he will continue to develop his skills at the professional level. The Cowboys are hopeful that Kneeland can become an integral part of their defensive rotation, providing consistent pressure on opposing quarterbacks and helping to solidify their defensive front. Days Until June 20th: Countdown & Planning Guide

Third Round Selection: Cooper Beebe, OG, Kansas State

The Cowboys further addressed their offensive line concerns in the third round by selecting Cooper Beebe, an offensive guard from Kansas State. Beebe is a highly decorated college player known for his intelligence, technique, and versatility. He has experience playing multiple positions on the offensive line, which adds to his value and fit within the Cowboys' system. Beebe’s strength and ability to anchor against powerful defensive tackles make him a reliable interior lineman. His selection is seen as a smart move to add depth and competition to the guard position.

Beebe’s addition provides the Cowboys with a potential starter at guard and valuable insurance in case of injuries along the offensive line. His proven track record and adaptability make him a strong candidate to contribute early in his career. The Cowboys are looking for Beebe to bring stability and toughness to their offensive line, helping to create running lanes and protect Dak Prescott. His football IQ and work ethic should allow him to quickly integrate into the Cowboys' offensive scheme and become a key contributor.

Analyzing Day 3 Picks and Overall Draft Grade

The Cowboys continued to add depth and potential talent on Day 3 of the draft, making several selections aimed at various positions of need. These picks often involve players with specific skill sets or developmental potential, adding to the overall composition of the draft class. Evaluating the success of Day 3 picks typically requires a longer-term perspective, as these players may need time to develop and find their roles within the team.

Fourth Round Selection: Caelen Carson, CB, Wake Forest

In the fourth round, the Cowboys selected Caelen Carson, a cornerback from Wake Forest. Carson is known for his physicality and aggressive style of play, making him a potentially valuable addition to the Cowboys' secondary. His ability to press receivers at the line of scrimmage and disrupt routes aligns well with the defensive scheme. Carson’s toughness and willingness to tackle are traits that the Cowboys value in their defensive backs. This pick aims to add depth and competition to the cornerback position, providing defensive coordinator Mike Zimmer with additional options in coverage.

Carson’s selection addresses the Cowboys' need for additional cornerback depth, providing a player with the potential to develop into a starter. His physicality and aggressive play style fit well with the Cowboys' defensive philosophy. The coaching staff will focus on refining Carson’s technique and consistency, but his natural talent and competitive spirit give him a strong chance to contribute on special teams and in defensive packages. The Cowboys are hoping Carson can become a reliable presence in their secondary, adding to their overall defensive strength.

Fifth Round Selection: Brenden Rice, WR, USC

The Cowboys picked Brenden Rice, a wide receiver from USC, in the fifth round, adding another target to their receiving corps. Rice, son of NFL legend Jerry Rice, brings a combination of size, speed, and strong hands to the field. His ability to make contested catches and contribute in the red zone makes him an intriguing prospect for the Cowboys' offense. Rice’s pedigree and work ethic suggest he has the potential to develop into a valuable receiving threat. This pick provides the Cowboys with additional depth at wide receiver and a player with the potential to make an impact in specific situations. Jacksonville TV Guide: Listings & Schedules

Rice’s addition offers the Cowboys another option in their passing game, providing a bigger-bodied receiver who can compete for jump balls and make tough catches. His experience and familiarity with the game, given his family background, give him a head start in understanding the nuances of the position. The Cowboys will look to integrate Rice into their offensive scheme, utilizing his size and hands to create mismatches and scoring opportunities. His development will be closely watched, as he has the potential to become a valuable asset in the Cowboys' passing attack.

Sixth Round Selection: Justin Rogers, DT, Auburn

In the sixth round, the Cowboys selected Justin Rogers, a defensive tackle from Auburn, adding depth to their interior defensive line. Rogers is a powerful run-stopping presence with the potential to develop into a rotational player. His strength and ability to hold his ground at the point of attack are traits that the Cowboys value in their defensive tackles. Rogers’ selection provides the Cowboys with additional depth along the defensive line and a player who can contribute in run-stopping situations.

Rogers' addition reinforces the Cowboys' defensive front, providing a physical presence in the interior. His ability to disrupt running plays and occupy blockers will be valuable in the Cowboys' defensive scheme. The coaching staff will focus on refining Rogers’ technique and improving his pass-rushing skills, but his strength and toughness give him a solid foundation to build upon. The Cowboys are hoping Rogers can develop into a reliable contributor in their defensive line rotation, helping to solidify their run defense.

Seventh Round Selection: Nathan Thomas, OT, Louisiana

The Cowboys selected Nathan Thomas, an offensive tackle from Louisiana, in the seventh round. Thomas is a developmental prospect with the size and athleticism to potentially contribute as a backup tackle. His selection adds depth to the offensive line and provides the Cowboys with a player to groom for the future. Thomas’ raw talent and work ethic make him an intriguing late-round pick with the potential to exceed expectations.

Thomas’ addition provides the Cowboys with an additional offensive line prospect to develop. His size and athleticism give him the tools to potentially contribute as a swing tackle in the future. The Cowboys’ coaching staff will focus on refining Thomas’ technique and improving his consistency, but his physical attributes make him a worthwhile investment in the seventh round. The Cowboys are hoping Thomas can develop into a reliable backup, adding to their offensive line depth.

Overall Draft Grade

Assigning an overall grade to the Dallas Cowboys' 2024 NFL Draft requires considering several factors, including the talent acquired, the value obtained at each pick, and the overall fit within the team's needs and scheme. Based on these considerations, the Cowboys' draft class receives a B+. The Cowboys addressed their most pressing needs by selecting Tyler Guyton and Cooper Beebe, bolstering their offensive line, and adding a potential pass-rushing threat in Marshawn Kneeland. The Day 3 picks offer additional depth and potential, though their impact remains to be seen.

The success of this draft will ultimately depend on the development of these players and their ability to contribute on the field. The Cowboys have invested in talent and potential, but the coaching staff's ability to mold these players into impactful contributors will be the key to the draft class's success. The early returns are promising, and the Cowboys appear to have positioned themselves well for the future.

Key Takeaways and Future Outlook

The Dallas Cowboys' 2024 NFL Draft reflects a strategic approach to addressing key roster needs while also adding depth and potential for the future. The selections made indicate a focus on both immediate impact and long-term development, which is crucial for sustained success in the NFL. The Cowboys' success in the upcoming seasons will be closely tied to the performance and growth of their draft class. This section summarizes the key takeaways from the draft and assesses the future outlook for the Cowboys based on their selections.

The Cowboys' primary focus on the offensive line in the early rounds demonstrates their commitment to protecting Dak Prescott and establishing a strong running game. The selections of Tyler Guyton and Cooper Beebe provide immediate competition and potential long-term solutions at crucial positions. Their ability to contribute early in their careers will be vital for the Cowboys' offensive success. The addition of Marshawn Kneeland bolsters the defensive line, providing a much-needed pass-rushing presence. His versatility and high motor make him a valuable asset to the defense. The Day 3 picks, including Caelen Carson and Brenden Rice, add depth and potential at cornerback and wide receiver, respectively. These players will have the opportunity to compete for roles on the team and contribute on special teams. The overall success of the draft class will depend on the development of these players and their ability to integrate into the Cowboys' system. The coaching staff will play a critical role in nurturing their talent and maximizing their potential.

Looking ahead, the Cowboys have positioned themselves to compete in the NFC East and make a playoff push. The additions from this draft class should strengthen key areas of the team and provide valuable depth. However, the true measure of the draft's success will be seen on the field, as these players begin their NFL careers and contribute to the team's performance. The Cowboys' front office and coaching staff will be closely monitoring their progress, looking for signs that they are developing into impactful players. The future looks promising for the Cowboys, but the journey from potential to performance will be a key storyline to follow in the coming seasons.

FAQ: Dallas Cowboys Draft Grade

How did the Cowboys address their offensive line needs in the draft?

The Dallas Cowboys made a concerted effort to address their offensive line needs by selecting Tyler Guyton in the first round and Cooper Beebe in the third round. Guyton, an offensive tackle, is expected to compete for a starting role, while Beebe, an offensive guard, adds depth and versatility to the interior line. These additions should help bolster the Cowboys' offensive front and protect quarterback Dak Prescott.

What impact is Marshawn Kneeland expected to make on the Cowboys' defense?

Marshawn Kneeland, a second-round pick, is expected to make an immediate impact on the Cowboys' defense as a pass rusher. Kneeland’s strength and high motor make him a valuable addition to the defensive line rotation. The Cowboys are hopeful that Kneeland can provide consistent pressure on opposing quarterbacks, helping to improve their overall defensive performance. His versatility allows him to play multiple positions along the defensive line, offering flexibility for defensive coordinator Mike Zimmer.

Why did the Cowboys draft Brenden Rice in the fifth round?

The Cowboys drafted Brenden Rice, a wide receiver from USC, in the fifth round to add depth and potential to their receiving corps. Rice brings a combination of size, speed, and strong hands to the field, making him an intriguing prospect. The Cowboys are looking for Rice to compete for a role in the offense and potentially contribute in the red zone. His pedigree, as the son of NFL legend Jerry Rice, also adds to his appeal.

What is the overall grade for the Cowboys' 2024 NFL Draft class?

The Dallas Cowboys' 2024 NFL Draft class receives an overall grade of B+. This grade reflects the Cowboys' success in addressing their primary needs, particularly on the offensive line and defensive front. The early-round selections of Tyler Guyton, Marshawn Kneeland, and Cooper Beebe are seen as strong picks, while the Day 3 selections add depth and potential. The ultimate success of the draft will depend on the development of these players.

How does the Cowboys' draft class compare to their NFC East rivals?

Comparing the Cowboys' draft class to their NFC East rivals requires a detailed analysis of each team's selections and needs. While a comprehensive comparison is beyond the scope of this article, it's fair to say that the Cowboys' focus on addressing key needs and adding potential impact players aligns with a competitive approach within the division. The success of each team's draft will become clearer as the players develop and contribute on the field.

What is the long-term outlook for the Cowboys based on this draft?

The long-term outlook for the Cowboys appears promising based on their 2024 NFL Draft. The additions made in this draft address immediate needs and provide potential for future growth. The Cowboys have positioned themselves to compete in the NFC East and make a playoff push, and the development of their draft class will be crucial to their sustained success. The team's focus on both immediate impact and long-term potential is a positive sign for their future.

How will the Cowboys' coaching staff impact the development of these rookies?

The Cowboys' coaching staff will play a critical role in the development of their rookies. The staff's ability to nurture talent, refine technique, and integrate these players into the team's system will be key to their success. The Cowboys have a track record of developing young players, and their coaching staff is well-equipped to guide this year's draft class. The progress of these rookies will be closely monitored as they transition to the NFL.

Where can I find more in-depth analysis of each Cowboys draft pick?

For more in-depth analysis of each Cowboys draft pick, you can visit reputable sports news websites such as ESPN (https://www.espn.com/nfl/draft), NFL.com (https://www.nfl.com/draft/), and The Athletic (https://theathletic.com/). These sites offer detailed scouting reports, expert opinions, and player profiles that can provide a comprehensive understanding of each selection. Additionally, local Dallas-Fort Worth sports media outlets often provide extensive coverage of the Cowboys' draft picks.

Photo of Robert M. Wachter

Robert M. Wachter

Professor, Medicine Chair, Department of Medicine ·

Robert M. Bob Wachter is an academic physician and author. He is on the faculty of University of California, San Francisco, where he is chairman of the Department of Medicine, the Lynne and Marc Benioff Endowed Chair in Hospital Medicine, and the Holly Smith Distinguished Professor in Science and Medicine