2009 NFL Draft: Complete Recap, Top Picks, And Analysis

The 2009 NFL Draft, held from April 25–26, 2009, at Radio City Music Hall in New York City, saw the Detroit Lions select quarterback Matthew Stafford as the first overall pick. This draft was notable for its strong quarterback class and several high-profile trades that reshaped team rosters. A detailed recap of the event, including top picks, significant trades, and overall draft analysis, provides valuable insights into the future landscape of the NFL.

Top Picks and Key Selections

The 2009 NFL Draft featured a number of highly touted prospects, particularly at the quarterback position. Several teams made significant investments to secure their future franchise quarterbacks and other key players. Analyzing the top selections provides a glimpse into the strategies and priorities of NFL teams during this period.

First Round Highlights

The first round of the 2009 NFL Draft was filled with anticipation as teams vied for top talent. Matthew Stafford, the quarterback from the University of Georgia, was selected first overall by the Detroit Lions. Stafford's strong arm and potential made him an attractive prospect for the Lions, who were looking to rebuild their offense. The St. Louis Rams followed by selecting Jason Smith, an offensive tackle from Baylor University, with the second overall pick. Smith was expected to bolster the Rams' offensive line and provide protection for their quarterback. The Kansas City Chiefs, with the third overall pick, chose defensive end Tyson Jackson from Louisiana State University. Jackson was seen as a powerful and versatile defender who could contribute to the Chiefs' defensive line. How To Run A Six-Team Double Elimination Bracket

Beyond the top three, the first round included several other notable selections. The Seattle Seahawks, picking fourth, selected linebacker Aaron Curry from Wake Forest University. Curry was regarded as one of the top defensive prospects in the draft and was expected to make an immediate impact for the Seahawks. The Cleveland Browns, at fifth overall, selected linebacker Clay Matthews III from the University of Southern California. Matthews, the son and nephew of NFL legends, brought a pedigree and pass-rushing ability that the Browns coveted. The Cincinnati Bengals chose offensive tackle Andre Smith from the University of Alabama with the sixth overall pick. Smith's size and strength made him a valuable addition to the Bengals' offensive line. The Oakland Raiders, picking seventh, selected wide receiver Darrius Heyward-Bey from the University of Maryland. Heyward-Bey's speed and athleticism were intriguing to the Raiders, who were looking to add a playmaker to their receiving corps. The Jacksonville Jaguars selected Eugene Monroe, an offensive tackle from the University of Virginia, with the eighth overall pick, adding strength to their offensive line.

Rounding out the top ten, the San Francisco 49ers chose Michael Crabtree, a wide receiver from Texas Tech University, at tenth overall. Crabtree's impressive college career made him one of the most highly regarded receivers in the draft. These top ten picks highlighted the diverse needs of NFL teams and their strategies for building competitive rosters through the draft.

Quarterback Class of 2009

The 2009 NFL Draft is particularly remembered for its strong quarterback class, with multiple players being selected in the early rounds. Besides Matthew Stafford going first overall, several other quarterbacks were drafted who went on to have significant NFL careers. Josh Freeman from Kansas State University was selected 17th overall by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Freeman was seen as a quarterback with a strong arm and leadership qualities, whom the Buccaneers hoped would lead their offense. Mark Sanchez from the University of Southern California was chosen fifth overall by the New York Jets. Sanchez's charisma and potential caught the Jets' attention, as they were in search of a franchise quarterback.

The presence of these quarterbacks in the first round underscored the importance NFL teams placed on the position. The teams selecting these quarterbacks were betting on their potential to become long-term starters and franchise cornerstones. The success of these quarterbacks varied, but their selections highlighted the constant demand for quality quarterback play in the NFL. The 2009 draft class also included other notable quarterbacks selected in later rounds, such as Curtis Painter and Rhett Bomar, who, while not achieving the same level of success as the first-round picks, added depth to their respective teams. Harris For President Merch: Show Your Support!

Notable Selections Beyond the First Round

While the first round garners the most attention, the later rounds of the NFL Draft often reveal hidden gems and valuable contributors. Several players selected outside the first round in 2009 went on to have productive NFL careers.

One notable example is LeSean McCoy, a running back from the University of Pittsburgh, who was selected by the Philadelphia Eagles in the second round (53rd overall). McCoy became one of the league's premier running backs, known for his agility and playmaking ability. His selection demonstrated the Eagles' ability to identify talent beyond the first round.

Another significant pick was wide receiver Jeremy Maclin from the University of Missouri, also selected by the Philadelphia Eagles in the first round (19th overall). Maclin proved to be a reliable target, showcasing his speed and route-running skills.

Sean Smith, a cornerback from the University of Utah, was drafted by the Miami Dolphins in the second round (61st overall). Smith developed into a solid defensive player, contributing to the Dolphins' secondary.

These later-round selections illustrate the importance of thorough scouting and player evaluation in the NFL Draft process. Teams that can identify talent in the later rounds often gain a competitive advantage, adding depth and potential starters to their rosters.

Significant Trades and Draft Day Deals

Trades are a common occurrence during the NFL Draft, as teams maneuver to position themselves to select specific players or accumulate more draft picks. The 2009 NFL Draft was no exception, with several significant trades reshaping the draft order and impacting team strategies. These trades often reflect teams' urgency to address specific needs or capitalize on perceived value in the draft class.

Notable Trades of 2009 NFL Draft

One of the most notable trades of the 2009 NFL Draft involved the Denver Broncos, who traded their first-round pick (12th overall) to the New York Jets. In exchange, the Broncos received the Jets' first-round pick (17th overall), their second-round pick (52nd overall), and several other picks. This trade allowed the Jets to move up and select quarterback Mark Sanchez, while the Broncos acquired additional draft capital to address multiple needs on their roster.

Another significant trade involved the Green Bay Packers, who traded their first-round pick (9th overall) to the Green Bay Packers. In return, the Packers received an additional pick. This trade allowed the Packers to move down in the draft order and still select a player they valued while adding more draft assets.

These trades highlight the strategic considerations teams weigh during the draft. Moving up in the draft often comes at a cost, but it can be worthwhile if a team is targeting a specific player. Conversely, trading down can provide a team with more flexibility and the opportunity to fill multiple roster holes.

Impact of Trades on Team Strategies

The trades made during the 2009 NFL Draft had a significant impact on team strategies and the overall draft landscape. Teams that traded up were often targeting specific players they believed could be franchise cornerstones, while teams that traded down were looking to maximize their draft assets and address multiple needs.

For example, the Jets' trade to acquire Mark Sanchez reflected their urgency to find a franchise quarterback. By moving up in the draft, they were able to secure their top target and address a critical need. Similarly, the Broncos' decision to trade down allowed them to accumulate more picks and add depth to their roster across multiple positions.

The trades also created ripple effects throughout the draft, as teams adjusted their strategies based on the moves of others. A trade by one team could impact the availability of players at certain positions, influencing the decisions of other teams. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for analyzing the overall impact of the draft on the NFL landscape. USF Vs. Boise State: Football Game Analysis & Preview

Draft Analysis and Long-Term Impact

Analyzing the 2009 NFL Draft requires looking beyond the immediate selections and considering the long-term impact on teams and the league as a whole. The success of a draft class is often judged by the number of players who become long-term starters, Pro Bowlers, and even potential Hall of Famers. Evaluating the draft's long-term impact involves assessing how well teams addressed their needs and how the selected players performed over their careers.

Evaluating Team Performances

Several teams made notable selections in the 2009 NFL Draft that paid dividends in the years that followed. The Detroit Lions' selection of Matthew Stafford, despite some initial struggles, ultimately provided the team with a franchise quarterback who led them to multiple playoff appearances. The Philadelphia Eagles' drafting of LeSean McCoy proved to be a significant success, as McCoy became one of the league's top running backs.

However, not all selections pan out as expected. Some high draft picks fail to live up to their potential due to injuries, performance issues, or other factors. Evaluating team performances requires a comprehensive look at the careers of the players selected and their contributions to their respective teams.

Long-Term Success Stories

Several players from the 2009 NFL Draft went on to have highly successful NFL careers. Matthew Stafford, despite playing for a struggling Lions franchise for many years, showcased his talent and durability, eventually leading the Los Angeles Rams to a Super Bowl victory. Clay Matthews III became a dominant pass rusher for the Green Bay Packers, earning multiple Pro Bowl selections and a Super Bowl ring. LeSean McCoy's success with the Eagles and later with the Buffalo Bills solidified his status as one of the premier running backs of his era.

These success stories highlight the potential impact of a well-executed draft. Identifying and selecting players who can perform at a high level for many years is the ultimate goal of every NFL team during the draft process.

Missed Opportunities and Busts

Conversely, the 2009 NFL Draft also had its share of missed opportunities and players who did not live up to expectations. Some high draft picks struggled to adapt to the NFL or were plagued by injuries, hindering their careers.

For example, Jason Smith, the second overall pick by the St. Louis Rams, faced numerous injuries and inconsistent performance, ultimately failing to become the cornerstone offensive tackle the Rams had hoped for. These instances serve as a reminder of the inherent risks involved in the draft process and the challenges of predicting a player's future success.

FAQ About the 2009 NFL Draft

What were the main storylines heading into the 2009 NFL Draft?

The main storylines heading into the 2009 NFL Draft revolved around the strong quarterback class, led by Matthew Stafford, and the potential for several high-profile trades. Teams needing a quarterback were expected to make aggressive moves, and the overall depth of talent at other positions also generated considerable interest.

Who was the first overall pick in the 2009 NFL Draft, and which team selected him?

Matthew Stafford, a quarterback from the University of Georgia, was the first overall pick in the 2009 NFL Draft. He was selected by the Detroit Lions, who were looking to find a franchise quarterback to lead their team. Stafford's strong arm and potential made him an attractive prospect.

Which quarterbacks were drafted in the first round of the 2009 NFL Draft?

In addition to Matthew Stafford, two other quarterbacks were selected in the first round of the 2009 NFL Draft: Mark Sanchez, who was picked fifth overall by the New York Jets, and Josh Freeman, who was selected 17th overall by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. This demonstrated the high value placed on the quarterback position.

Were there any major surprises or unexpected picks during the 2009 NFL Draft?

One notable surprise was the Oakland Raiders' selection of Darrius Heyward-Bey with the seventh overall pick. Heyward-Bey was considered a reach by many analysts, as he was not widely projected to be a top-ten pick. This pick highlighted the Raiders' tendency to value speed and athleticism.

How is the success of the 2009 NFL Draft class generally viewed in hindsight?

The 2009 NFL Draft class is generally viewed as a mixed bag. While it produced several successful players who had long and productive careers, there were also a number of high draft picks who did not live up to expectations. The overall success is contingent on individual team evaluations.

What are some examples of notable players drafted outside the first round in 2009?

LeSean McCoy, selected in the second round, became one of the NFL's premier running backs. Another notable player drafted outside the first round was Sean Smith, a cornerback who had a solid career after being drafted in the second round. These players highlight the importance of scouting beyond the first round.

What impact did trades have on the outcome of the 2009 NFL Draft?

Trades significantly impacted the 2009 NFL Draft, particularly the New York Jets' trade to acquire Mark Sanchez. These trades reshaped the draft order and allowed teams to address specific needs or accumulate more draft picks, influencing the overall draft strategy and player selection.

Which teams are considered to have had the best and worst drafts in 2009?

Evaluating which teams had the best and worst drafts is subjective and depends on long-term player performance. However, teams like the Philadelphia Eagles, who drafted LeSean McCoy and Jeremy Maclin, are often cited as having successful drafts. Teams with multiple high picks who did not pan out might be viewed less favorably in hindsight.

Conclusion

The 2009 NFL Draft was a pivotal event that shaped the landscape of the league for years to come. From the selection of Matthew Stafford as the first overall pick to the various trades and surprises that unfolded, the draft provided a glimpse into the strategies and priorities of NFL teams. The long-term success stories and missed opportunities from this draft continue to be analyzed and debated, highlighting the complexities of player evaluation and the enduring impact of draft decisions on team performance.

External Resources

  1. NFL Official Website: https://www.nfl.com/
  2. ESPN NFL Coverage: https://www.espn.com/nfl/
  3. Pro Football Reference: https://www.pro-football-reference.com/
Photo of Robert M. Wachter

Robert M. Wachter

Professor, Medicine Chair, Department of Medicine ·

Robert M. Bob Wachter is an academic physician and author. He is on the faculty of University of California, San Francisco, where he is chairman of the Department of Medicine, the Lynne and Marc Benioff Endowed Chair in Hospital Medicine, and the Holly Smith Distinguished Professor in Science and Medicine